10 Years of the SPL - Progress?

The place to discuss Scottish football
Scottish
Site Admin
Posts: 7665
Joined: Sat Jun 11, 2005 4:51 pm
Contact:

Post by Scottish » Thu Oct 09, 2008 9:13 am

Skyline Drifter wrote:Likewise the EPL race for relegation is at least as 'interesting' as that in the SPL. More so in fact as more sides are involved and whilst in the SPL one side doing a Gretna ends all interest in it, in the EPL it's fairly unlikely that three clubs will be marooned with months to go.
Virtually impossible in fact. Circumstances would have to be freakish to produce three teams cut off from the rest. The nearest I can think of was in 2004-05 when it was clear well before the end that Chelsea would win the league and three out of four would go down. But it still provided a gripping last day of the season.

While England has drifted towards the model of most other countries in having a few dominant sides at one end and promoted teams struggling at the other relegation remains competitive with three clubs going down. In the first few years of its existence the SPL couldn't even guarantee that any club would be relegated.

lbb
Posts: 1316
Joined: Thu Jun 22, 2006 10:25 am
Contact:

Post by lbb » Thu Oct 09, 2008 10:07 am

deltech wrote: Not withstanding the other comments in this thread, I truly do not see the attraction in these "must see" English fixtures you refer to. Having lived in England since 1993 and been to several TOP League fixtures, an watched an excrement-load (auto-editted) of games on TV, I can honestly say that the majority of the games in their Top League are arguably not worth watching. The real talent in that League lies with a small handful of teams, notably Manchester United (consistently) Liverpool (inconsistently) Chelsea (only recently) Arsenal (previously).
You're certainly entitled to that view and I know some others who share it. However, it's undoubtely true that Sky did help create enormous media interest in a game which only a few years earlier had been cast out of European football and had club chairmen talking about electric fences to keep supporters in. The English game couldn't have been more unfashionable in the late 1980's but, for a variety of reasons including Sky, they were able to transform it in the 1990's attracting, for good and bad, a lot of new supporters and global interest.

My own take on it was that the major Scottish clubs thought they could repeat the trick in the late 1990's, on a smaller scale, but were unable to do so.

I disagree with the view that the predictability at the top-end of the English Premiership has some kind of comparison with the SPL. There's a world of difference in the quality of the two leagues and this sustains a huge amount of interest by itself. Yes, West Ham or Aston Villa might not win anything but you'll watch some good players, some decent matches in a modern stadium which is nearly almost always full. This is a totally different 'football experience' from that outwith the Old Firm in the SPL, in my view.

In saying all that, I don't watch the Premiership as much as I used to. Watching one set of millionaires play another set of millionaires for the benefit of some Russian/Saudi Arabian billionaires is less appealling to me nowadays. But it's still incredibly popular to a huge number of supporters.
deltech wrote:Further, no amount of SKY razamataz can actually improve the quality of an otherwise mundane and insignificant match involving such QUALITY teams as Aston Villa, Birmingham, Blackburn Rovers, Bolton (post-McGinley of course), Derby, Fulham, Hull City, Leeds (remember them?), Middlesburgh, Newcastle, Portsmouth, Preston, Reading, Stoke City, West Brom, West Ham, Wigan, to name but a few.
Blackburn Rovers have players like Roque Santa Cruz - a player who would comfortably grace the SPL. Stillian Petrov, a player who was a huge star at Celtic, is now an Aston Villa squad player. Some of the names in there are nothing special but Sky money has allowed most clubs in the Premiership to have at least 1 or 2 really talented players in their squad. I'm not going to disagree that Sky hype mundane fixtures - I more or less said as much earlier.

Post Reply

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests